
NBA legend Michael Jordan once stated that, “To learn to succeed, you must learn to fail.”
For now 17-year-old NorCal phenom Asterisk Talley, there have certainly been some major bumps on her road to success. In 2024, Talley, the all-time winningest player on the Junior Tour of Northern California, finished runner-up at the U.S. Women’s Amateur and U.S. Girls’ Junior.
In 2025, meanwhile, she heartbreakingly lost the lead at the Augusta National Women’s Amateur.
For Talley, who resides in Chowchilla, the lessons from those failures loomed large on her way to reaching the top of the mountain.
In June, Talley first made noise by setting a U.S. Women’s Open record by posting the lowest weekend round by an amateur with a bogey-free 5-under 66 in the third round.
Two months later, Talley slayed any demons from the past, capturing the title at the 126th U.S. Women’s Amateur.
The two performances, along with a win on the JTNC, helped Talley claim her second NCGA Women’s Player of the Year crown with a final total of 1,800 points. Lily Peng, who earned NCGA Junior Girls’ Player of the Year honors, was runner-up with 1,295 points.
“Winning NCGA Player of the Year honors means a lot to me, especially since the NCGA is what shaped me into the golfer I am today,” Talley said. “The NCGA has been my home since I was little and I am happy to represent them on every level.”
Talley, who also won POY honors in 2024 and is a member of the U.S. National Junior Team, relied heavily on her mental game en route to winning her second national title (she won the 2024 U.S. Women’s Amateur Four-Ball with partner Sarah Lim). One day during the U.S. Women’s Amateur, she had to play 39 holes due to rain delays.
As Talley explains, her game isn’t the only thing that has grown. She is also just more mature now.
“I realize more now that golf doesn’t define me as a person,” Talley said. “Making a 4-footer to win an event doesn’t make me a better person at the end of the day, and coming to terms with that has made me feel comfortable in my game and with my results.”
Looking ahead, Annika Borrelli for now remains the lone female to win POY honors three times (2019, ’21, ’22). It’s a safe bet that Talley, who’ll either begin playing at Stanford in the fall of 2027 or turn professional, could join her within the next two years if she remains an amateur.